---
description: Compare Recurly vs Butter Payments. Learn more about each of the software’s price, features, and helpful software reviews for Irish business users.
image: https://gdm-localsites-assets-gfprod.imgix.net/images/capterra/og_logo-e5a8c001ed0bd1bb922639230fcea71a.png?auto=format%2Cenhance%2Ccompress
title: Recurly vs Butter Payments Comparison - Capterra Ireland 2026
---

Breadcrumb: [Home](/) > [Recurring Billing Software](/directory/30927/recurring-billing/software) > [Recurly \<span\>vs\</span\> Butter Payments](https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments)

# Compare Recurly vs Butter Payments

Canonical: https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments

> Detailed comparison between Recurly and Butter Payments. Check ratings, reviews, pricing, and features to make the best decision for your business.

-----

## At a Glance

| Metric | Recurly | Butter Payments |
| **Overall rating** | 4.6/5 | 5.0/5 |
| **Total Reviews** | 62 | 1 |
| **Starting Price** | US$0.00 | - |
| **Free Trial** | Yes | Yes |
| **Free Version** | Yes | No |
| **Deployment** | Cloud, SaaS, Web-based | Cloud, SaaS, Web-based |
| **Support** | Email/Help Desk, FAQs/Forum, Phone Support, Chat | Email/Help Desk, FAQs/Forum, Knowledge Base, Phone Support, Chat |
| **Training** | Live Online, Webinars, Documentation, Videos | In Person, Live Online, Webinars, Documentation |

## Best for

### Recurly

Recurly is ideal for DTC, high-velocity, high-volume companies -- in the digital media, streaming, publishing, SaaS, education, consumer goods, and services industries -- that are looking to scale.

### Butter Payments

Butter Payments is built for DTC subscription brands and SaaS businesses with more than $10m+ in annual recurring revenue, on average adding 5%+ ARR growth.

## Key features

### Recurly

- Accounting
- Alerts/Notifications
- Cancellation Management
- Credit Card Processing
- Customisable Templates
- Dunning Management
- Electronic Payments
- Invoice Management
- Multi-Currency
- Partial Payments
- Real-Time Analytics
- Real-Time Data
- Recurring/Subscription Billing
- Reminders
- Revenue Management
- Subscription Management
- Subscription Plan Management
- Summary Reports
- Transaction History
- Usage Tracking/Analytics

### Butter Payments

- Alerts/Notifications
- Credit Card Processing
- Dunning Management
- Electronic Payments
- Invoice Management
- Multi-Currency
- Real-Time Analytics
- Recurring/Subscription Billing
- Revenue Management
- Subscription Management
- Summary Reports
- Transaction History
- Usage Tracking/Analytics

## Links

- [View Recurly Profile](https://www.capterra.ie/software/122700/recurly-subscription-billing)
- [View Butter Payments Profile](https://www.capterra.ie/software/1064909/butter-payments)
- [View Original Comparison](https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments)

-----

## Structured Data

<script type="application/ld+json">
  {"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"name":"Recurly vs Butter Payments Comparison - Capterra Ireland 2026","description":"Compare Recurly vs Butter Payments. Learn more about each of the software’s price, features, and helpful software reviews for Irish business users.","url":"https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments","about":[{"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/software/122700/recurly-subscription-billing#software"},{"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/software/1064909/butter-payments#software"}],"breadcrumb":{"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments#breadcrumblist"},"@type":["WebPage","CollectionPage"],"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments#webpage","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/#organization"},"inLanguage":"en-IE","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/#website"}},{"name":"Recurly","description":"Category-defining companies like Sling, Twitch, FabFitFun, Paramount+, and Sprout Social choose Recurly to manage billions of dollars in recurring revenues, future-proof their recurring billing and revenue management, and recover billions of dollars in lost revenue due to churn. \n\nOur all-in-one, integrated platform removes the complexities of automating subscription billing by enabling teams to manage and optimize their subscriber lifecycles with ease. Keep a good thing growingTM","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/26fb3bf0-c469-4c53-958d-4c472c55e3eb.png","url":"https://www.capterra.ie/software/122700/recurly-subscription-billing","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/software/122700/recurly-subscription-billing#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","bestRating":5,"ratingCount":62,"ratingValue":4.6},"offers":{"price":"0","@type":"Offer","priceCurrency":"USD"},"operatingSystem":"Cloud"},{"name":"Butter Payments","description":"Every 90 seconds a payment fails and you lose money. Most subscription businesses see ~50% of churn due to failed payments. Businesses like yours lose 9-11% of their revenue for this one reason. Butter is where churn ends, recovering failed payments faster, and more efficiently, typically leading to 5%+ increase in ARR. \n\nUsing AI and machine learning, Butter optimizes your payment recovery strategy based on your business—your subscription(s), your customer, your payment stack and your processes to maximize the recovery of revenue and customers. By partnering with Butter, merchants can enhance their payment health, increase retention, and deliver revenue faster to accelerate growth and maximize profits.\n\nClients include Fabletics, The Athletic, Dialpad, Dr. Squatch, Athena Club, Savage X Fenty, Found, Wyze Labs, airSlate, Tonal, JustFab, Hairstory, Eucalyptus, UrbanSitter, Simple, Bloom, Perlego, MuseScore, KitUp, Speechify, and more.","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/148c2a0d-76c6-4ac9-ac71-7ffe07cee0b9.png","url":"https://www.capterra.ie/software/1064909/butter-payments","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/software/1064909/butter-payments#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","bestRating":5,"ratingCount":1,"ratingValue":5.0},"operatingSystem":"Cloud"},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"name":"Home","position":1,"item":"/","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Recurring Billing Software","position":2,"item":"/directory/30927/recurring-billing/software","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Recurly vs Butter Payments","position":3,"item":"https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments","@type":"ListItem"}],"@id":"https://www.capterra.ie/compare/122700/1064909/recurly-subscription-billing/vs/butter-payments#breadcrumblist"}]}
</script>